1. It’s the Bear scenario: Sri didn’t jump, she was pushed.In the past 24 hours, it’s become clear that Sri was pushed rather than jumped: At a breakfast meeting with her top finance officials yesterday, she indicated that she was ordered to accept the World Bank job by the President.
In yesterday’s From the Ground, we laid out a Bull and a Bear scenario, in which the Bull scenario involved Sri leaving in a co-coordinated fashion confident in the knowledge that she was victorious in the Bank Century affair and with a market-friendly successor in the wings.
With this latest colour, it appears that we are instead faced with the Bear scenario, which we described yesterday as follows:
· Aburizal Bakrie has won, after all.
· The President is still under the sphere of influence of the Bakries, after all.
· That the reform process risks becoming derailed.
2. Will the reform process become derailed? Before we launch the lifeboats, it’s important to note that the reform process has not been all about one person.
While Sri’s replacement might not be equally charismatic or forceful in pursuing the reform agenda, there are plenty of quotes in the newspapers this morning from the various players in the reformist movement that they expect their reformist work to continue, including the anti-corruption KPK and the anti-monopoly agency KPPU.
Key in this process is the President himself: He is presented with a great opportunity to show himself to be a great reformer and thus cement his legacy during the remainder of this second term. Go SBY!
3. Reaction from the Bonds and FX MarketsThe bond market’s knee jerk reaction yesterday was to mark down prices aggressively: There was an immediate across the curve 30-40bnps correction in yield, with the 10 year government bond starting the day at 8.5% and ending the day at 8.8%.
The currency traded weaker, with USD/IDR falling from 9,050 to the current level of 9,093. This fall would have been more dramatic, but for the intervention of Bank Indonesia buying IDR. Of late, Bank Indonesia has been buying USD to protect prevent the USD/IDR from trading below 9,000, so they no doubt enjoyed the opportunity to sell some of those USD back to the market for a profit.
It is worth noting that this immediate kneejerk increase in the bond yield represents a mere blip in the more dramatic broader decline in bond yields: Any number below 9% still qualifies as ‘near historic low levels’.
Our colleagues in fixed income tell us that yesterday traders were sellers while the real money was buying.
4. How is local sentiment?Based on our non-scientific survey of local market participants, local investors are not overly concerned about developments and are looking to buy.
As one local market participant related to us: “This is good because all the bickering in Parliament will end”.
5. How will foreigners investors react? Foreign investors are slightly overweight the MSCI’s Indonesia weighting (3% of Asia ex Japan), but similarly underweight the broader Indonesia opportunity (e.g. Indonesia’s weighting is less than Malaysia at 4.4%).
This could become a very detailed conversation at this point. However, to keep it simple we’ll refer to the chart below which shows that one should expect foreign investors to be net buyers into a significant correction, just as they have been in previous corrections.
6. Possible successors It seems that SBY was caught a little unprepared by the timing of the announcement of Sri’s departure, with the announcement coming from the World Bank rather than from within the administration (nice one Sri J).
Accordingly, there does not appear to be a successor waiting in the wings and at present talk of her successor is little more than speculation. So here’s some speculation:
Hatta Rajasa, currently Coordinating Minister of the Economy, will likely take over the role on an interim basis.
Anggito Abimanyu, currently Head of Fiscal Policy at the Finance Ministry.
Anny Ratnawati, currently DG of Budgeting at the Finance Ministry.
Darmin Nasution, currently acting BI Governor.
Fuad Rahmany, currently BAPEPAM (financial markets supervisory agency) Chairman.
Agus Martowardojo, currently Bank Mandiri CEO.
Armida Alisyahbana, currently Minister of Planning.
Eddy Abdurrachman, currently deputy Coordinating Minister.
Chatib Basri, currently advisor to the Finance Ministry.